I am not bound to win, but I am bound to be true. I am not bound to succeed, but I am bound to live by the light that I have.
--Abraham Lincoln
Showing posts with label Magical History Tour. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Magical History Tour. Show all posts

Friday, July 15, 2011

General James Longstreet: Defying the Stereotypes

What do Civil War General James Longstreet and U.S. Senator Strom Thurmond have in common?

They both served their country, they were both Republicans, and they were both born in Edgefield County, South Carolina. That’s not far from here—just the other side of Aiken County.

On the surface, it would seem they were mighty similar. But on closer inspection, they are radically different.

James Longstreet was second in command to Robert E. Lee at the Battle of Gettysburg. While he highly respected his superior, Longstreet held a different philosophy regarding war tactics. He petitioned strenuously for Lee to move to a defensive position between the Union Army and Washington, D.C. where they could find “ground to their own liking.”

Lee was an aggressive leader who, like Patton, had much success, yet high casualties. These traits did not serve him well in this pivotal battle. Analysts believe his command style did not suit the situation at Gettysburg, but Lee was unable to adapt. He, against the advice of many of his officers, decided to attack the middle of the Union forces on July 3, 1863.

Longstreet was reluctant to lead an assault he did not believe in, and reportedly asked to be replaced, but Lee refused. The film clip below shows Longstreet’s vision of what has become known as Pickett’s Charge.


I’ll write more details of that battle in my next post. For now, suffice it to say his prediction proved true.

After the war, he did the unpardonable in the eyes of the “Lost Cause Movement,” which romanticized the Confederacy. He publicly criticized Lee’s leadership at Gettysburg in his memoirs. Worse than that, he became a Republican after the war. This was not Strom Thurmond’s Republican Party (the party infamous for its Southern Strategy). No, this was Abraham Lincoln’s Republican Party. Longstreet served in the administration of Ulysses S. Grant. He advocated equal rights for blacks. For these reasons, he was vilified by his former compatriots.

In 1998, this statue of James Longstreet was one of the last to be erected. Compare it to that of Robert E. Lee (see "A Study in Courage" July 2, 2011 ). Rather than set upon a massive pedestal as most generals' statues there are, it is tucked into the trees and at ground level.

I wonder which took more courage for Longstreet—fighting the horrific battles of the Civil War or daring to hold unpopular beliefs among his own people.

Strom Thurmond, Longstreet’s fellow native son of Edgefield, fathered a black daughter while he labored to obliterate civil rights for African-Americans. Who showed integrity? Who pandered to white racist fears for his own advancement? I know who I admire.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

The Battle at Little Round Top

Wendy and I have often noted that, throughout history, every now and then a collection of exceptional people comes together to do amazing things. One of those collections would be our founding fathers. While there was much disagreement and struggle, the courageous minds of Jefferson, Franklin, and Adams (to name a few) came up with and instituted a radically unique and forward-thinking concept of government in which “all men are created equal”.

Yet, as we have been studying the Battle of Gettysburg in particular and the Civil War in general, we both have been struck by how many from either side made poor judgments or critical mistakes that lost or prolonged battles and even the entire war. It often seems like a cluster of unforced errors.

And yet, there shine forth examples of stellar leadership and extraordinary valor. One of these was at Little Round Top where the 20th Maine under Colonel Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain was posted on the second day of Gettysburg’s battle. Told they were the anchor of the entire Union line along Cemetery Ridge, they set themselves to hold the left flank or die trying. The 15th Alabama made a valiant effort to take the high ground following an arduous twenty-mile march. They surged up the hill again and again. Low on ammunition, Chamberlain ordered his men to fix bayonets and charge the Alabamians.

This is one of the highlights of the movie, “Gettysburg”, as seen in the clip below.


Since Chamberlain and Longstreet are my favorite figures from this battle, I was excited to stand on the spot where the engagement took place. I was struck by the rocky terrain the soldiers had to storm over. I would have stumbled over the first rock and bayonetted myself in the gut, I am sure.

Barbara standing where the 20th

Maine was positioned.
Some of the boulders were even
larger and more tenuous.

The view from Little Round Top.
Note the Pennsylvania Monument
that holds my ancestor's name far in
the background.




The monument to the 20th Maine.

In April 1865, Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain was approached by a messenger from the Confederate Army relaying that General Lee was interested in Grant's terms of surrender. At that ceremony at Appomattox Courthouse, Chamberlain was chosen to command the Union troops. As the Confederate soldiers marched down the road to surrender their arms, he ordered his men to come to attention as a show of respect. General Gordon, at the head of the Southern soldiers, ordered a reciprocal display of respect. Later, Gordon called Chamberlain "one of the knightliest soldiers of the Federal Army."

Saturday, July 2, 2011

A Study in Courage

What would you do if there were a fight? The U.S. Government versus your family and friends. Whose side would you be on? You may be laughing right now. “Come on. Give me a harder question,” you say.

Okay. You believe the government is right and your family is wrong. Now what do you do? You, as a person of honor? One who ranks integrity the highest of virtues? Not so simple, is it?

When we give a cursory glance to the Civil War, we see it as a done deal. Whatever side your ancestors were on, the call came. They went. They fought hard. Win or lose, they did their part with pride. Yet, it was anything but simple.

Robert E. Lee wrote to his son, "I can anticipate no greater calamity for the country than the dissolution of the Union. It would be an accumulation of all the evils we complain of, and I am willing to sacrifice everything but honor for its preservation."

A monument to Robert E. Lee astride his horse,
Traveler
This was written a month following South Carolina’s secession, but three months before Virginia followed suit. Once his home state joined the Confederacy, he had to decide how he wanted to dishonor himself—by breaking his vow to protect the Union as a commissioned officer in the United States Army or by turning against his state, his friends, and his family in that country’s defense.

Although Robert E. Lee has been mythologized and heroified into a two-dimensional figure, he was a real human being for whom everything was not black or white, right or wrong.

I, myself, have wished for simpler days when solutions stared you squarely in the face. You merely needed the courage “to do what is right.” Those days never were. Life has always been a clawing struggle to ask the right questions and seek the best answers when no perfect solution exists.

This internal struggle takes the greatest courage of all. I once heard that there are two kinds of people in the world—those who think and those who don’t think. It sounds funny at first, but it is deeply profound. Those who don’t think reject the pain of the internal struggle. They would rather follow the crowd, do as they are told. It is the more cowardly route. I venture to say we have all been there at one time or another.

From the lowest private to Robert E. Lee, many at Gettysburg had faced this dilemma. We are all confronted by such choices, large and small, today. I don’t know if Robert E. Lee made the right choice. I am not him. He alone could do that. But I honor him and all like him who confront an issue with integrity and bravely make a decision.

Today is the 148th anniversary of Day Two at the Battle of Gettysburg. Re-enactors are preparing to scramble up Little Round Top and Culp’s Hill. Battle strategy may be the focus of the day. When we think of courage, we imagine what it took to run toward the cannon fire, rather than away from it. But remember more the mettle it took these men to search their hearts and choose the better rather than the easier course of action.   

We desperately need that type of courage today.

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

The Truman Show

A chance for Judy to take goofy
pictures at the Visitor's Center.
On Wednesday, June 15th, we visited Gettysburg National Military Park. It was a gorgeous day—beautiful clear sky and a pleasant temperature. Upon arrival, we went to the Visitor’s Center and checked out the museum, watched a good film called “A New Birth of Freedom,” and observed a 360 degree painting of Pickett’s Charge. Very cool.

Wendy & I beside the
appropriate uniforms.
The park is huge and encompasses the town itself. There are 1500 monuments there which is quite overwhelming. Luckily, Barbara arranged an excellent tour for us all. There are many ways to see and experience the park. You can hike along Cemetery Ridge, bicycle with a guide, buy a tape with which to drive around on your own, scoot along on segways, or hop on a bus. I believe ours was the very best way to go. We had personal guides drive us around in our own cars. 
Segways look weird, but fun.


This is an amazingly good deal. To ride on a bus costs each person $28. For each carload of people, the fee is $55. If you have only two people in the car, you’ve already saved a buck! 

There were four of us in the Halligan’s car and I believe we got the better of the two guides. Judy grabbed the other guy for her, Mom, and Susan’s car because he was joking around pretty well.

Truman explains how we can identify an authentic
Civil War cannon. What didn't he know? 
But we got Truman.

He was more serious, it seemed, but boy, did he know his stuff. He started out by asking us what we already knew about the park and its history. Since we had read "Killer Angels," watched “Gettysburg,” and followed Civil War Week on the History Channel, he adjusted his tour accordingly, relating what we were seeing to what we already knew.

Truman actually grew up in Gettysburg, so I guess he has been immersed in its story his whole life. The best part about his presentation was his enthusiasm over the subject matter. He must have talked about this stuff ad nauseum, but you could tell he loved it. The sign of a great teacher.

He drove us all over, explaining the battle day by day. I wish I could remember all that he said, but over the next couple days, I will write about the stuff that stuck with me. The tour was scheduled for two hours, but Truman kept us going at a steady pace for two and a half. He was excellent.

I don’t know if they allow requests for guides, but if you go to Gettysburg, ask for Truman.

CONFESSION: I stole the first two photos off Susan's Facebook page. Thanks, Sue.

Monday, June 27, 2011

Family Time on the Tour

Our Magical History Tour was a great time for family. On Monday night after touring Philadelphia, Barbara, Mom, and I made our way to Freehold, New Jersey for a dinner with our Connor Cousins. There are eighteen of us from three generations in the picture, but I believe more had been there earlier. I know for a fact that Mary Ellen Kelly had to leave early.
Ignore the grease stain on my shirt.
On Tuesday, seven of us met at Drummer Boy Campground in Gettysburg. I give it five stars. The cabin slept eight and was clean, comfortable, and picturesque. Tommy Halligan grilled for us that evening and we had lots of laughs on the porch. Another highlight was our favorite game of chance, "Left, Right, Center". I won once and Wendy won twice. Good night for Team Gibson.

Our porch looked over a lovely pond
with a very active and vocal frog.


We love to laugh!












A great porch. Our group included Barbara and Tom, Mom,
Susan, Judy, Wendy, and me.

On Saturday, the clan met at Joanie’s house in Virginia Beach for Rebecca’s high school graduation party. Many of the relatives were able to attend and we had a great time. I miss backyard summer parties. South Carolina is just too hot for that. (Luck ran out, though, for "Left, Right, Center".)

Here is a majority of our family. The matriarch (or "matrix"
as Mom likes to call herself--don't ask)
is front and center. We had an excellent time.



Wednesday, June 22, 2011

The Cathedral Basilica of Saints Peter and Paul

As mentioned in a previous post (June 18 "John Connor of Philadelphia"), my Civil War ancestor was reputed to have married at the Cathedral Basilica of Saints Peter and Paul. The structure was unfinished at that time and looked quite different than it does today. I excitedly took photos of the altar area as the place my great-great grandparents married, only to discover that in 1957, the building was enlarged. The altar was moved and a new one--the present one--was installed. Oh well.

The cornerstone was laid in 1846, just two years after "The Philadelphia Nativist Riots" AKA "The Bible Riots" against Catholic immigrants and their churches. This was a tragic episode that has been repeated throughout our history from its beginning to this day. [Note that John McCain recently blamed Arizona wildfires on illegal immigrants with no basis in fact. History continues to repeat itself.]

Barbara before the
massive cathedral columns
With the influx of primarily Catholic immigrants to Philadelphia, fears of those already established Americans (nativists) were inflamed by rumors and half-truths. When a Philadelphia bishop approached the school board, he requested that Catholic children be permitted to read their Bible instead of the Protestant version used by all at the time. This was seen as reasonable and approved by the board.

About a year later, an untrue rumor was spread that the Catholics wanted the Bible removed from schools altogether. This sparked not-so-latent anti-Catholic sentiment that led to dreadful riots.These disturbances resulted in killings and burnings that the police could not quell. Only 5000 state troops were able to restore peace.

According to our custodian/tour guide, Jim, when the new cathedral was being designed, local seminarians were asked to stand in the middle of the church and throw rocks and stones as high as they could. The windows were placed just above the highest point. The lower walls of the cathedral have no windows at all.

I put my only good picture of the inside of the cathedral on the June 18th post. Below is a short video tour of the basilica from their website. Take a look. It is only two minutes and nine seconds long.


Mom in the crypt. Our guide Jim is
in the background
We got a special treat when Jim offered to take us into the crypt below the altar. Normally tours are given by people called ambassadors, but Jim said he had listened in on the tours enough that he could show us around. He was a nice guy and a real character.

The crypt contains the remains of several cardinals and archbishops from years gone by. The oldest are from the first bishop of Philadelphia, Michael Francis Egan, who died in 1814, more than thirty years before the cornerstone was laid. He and a couple others were exumed and reinterred when the church was built. Jim said the present archbishop would probably not be buried there "in stinkin' Philadelphia". Since he has connections in Rome, he will likely be laid to rest in the Vatican. (What a grandstander!)

On a final note, a seventy-one year old volunteer informed us that his daughter will be married there on July 9th. He claimed to be one of the younger of 613 parishoners there, so that weddings and baptisms of the congregation are rare anymore. I was amazed at the tiny number of members for so massive a church. He told us that weddings for non-members cost $2000 and they must also pay the local organist who alone is allowed to play for functions. These and other such events are how they keep afloat.

Well, the basilica has come a long way from the days when John Connor married there. How much do you think they charged him for the partially-finished cathedral?

Saturday, June 18, 2011

John Connor of Philadelphia

Thanks to some excellent genealogical research by my sister, Barbara Halligan, we were able to visit places significant to our ancestor, John Connor. This man was my grandfather’s grandfather.

Me at 2421 Manning Street
During the Civil War era, he lived in Philadelphia in a narrow, but neat row house that is still there. It was located at 2421 Manning Street, a road too narrow for even one car (we had to at times ride with one wheel on the curb). Unexpectedly, I was filled with emotion at the sight of his home and my eyes brimmed with tears.

Altar at Cathedral of Saints Peter
and Paul
Later that day, we visited the Cathedral of Saints Peter and Paul. I will write about the church later, but it is believed that John Connor married in this incredible structure before it was completed. A custodian there told Barbara that, if so, records at the church would confirm this. She will investigate at a later time.

Marker of the battle location
in Gettysburg
Last, when we visited Gettysburg, we visited the monument to John Connor’s unit. He joined the Thirty-first Infantry of the Second Pennsylvania Reserves. This unit engaged in several battles before and after Gettysburg, but it was inspirational to stand where the fighting of my ancestor took place.

On the monument, the description of their engagements read as follows: “July 2nd in the evening charged from the hill in rear [Little Round Top] to this position and held it until the afternoon of July 3rd when the brigade advanced through the woods to the front and left driving the enemy and capturing many prisoners.”

The battle referred to on July 3rd was Pickett’s Charge, a disaster for the Confederates. This Yankee regiment captured “six thousand stand of arms, the flag of the Fifteenth Georgia, and three hundred prisoners.” The Thirty-first lost ten men with thirty more wounded.*

The huge PA monument--
Can you see the people at
the top?

Pennsylvania had the most massive of all the monuments at Gettysburg. Our family lore says that John Connor’s son, a mason, worked on this structure. Again, it was moving to find John Connor’s name among the enlisted men.

Our dad, also John Connor, would have been very proud to have known all this about his great-grandfather.

*This information was found in History of Pennsylvania Volunteers, 1861-5; prepared in compliance with acts of the legislature, by Samuel P. Bates. The entire story of the Thirty-first can be located online at http://www.pacivilwar.com/bates.html

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Wit or Wit-Out

On Monday, our Magical History Tour took us to the City of Brotherly Love, AKA Kill-adelphia. We ate lunch at a landmark from the 1930s—Pat’s King of Steaks, birthplace of the Philly Cheesesteak.

First, let it be known that Steak-umms ought to be ashamed of themselves for such a pathetic imitation of the real thing. It’s like calling Carrot Top a good stand-in for Robert de Niro.

On the opposite corner from Pat’s is its rival, Geno’s. Apparently there is a long-standing feud in Philadelphia as to which is the premier cheesesteak. Our niece, Mary Ellen, is a resident of the city and she gave her blessing to Pat’s.

Charleston may have been voted America’s Most Polite City, but I imagine the staff of Pat’s would cackle over that. They blatantly discourage courtesy, preferring efficiency. Once you approach the order window, you are confronted by a blunt list of ordering rules. They are as follows:

“Step 1. Specify if you want your steak with (wit) or without (wit-out) onions. (If you are not a rookie, this should come naturally.)
Step 2. Specify plain - cheez whiz – provolone – American cheese or a pizza steak.
Step 3. Have your money ready. (Do all of your borrowing in line)
Step 4. Practice all of the above while waiting in line.
(If you make a mistake, don’t panic, just go to the back of the line and start over.)”

An online site about this procedure warned us not to waste any time with friendly greetings or chitchat. After practicing, I approached the window. “One, provolone, wit-out,” I said. Just like a pro. Wendy followed with, “Whiz, wit.” We were smooth.

At the next window, we placed our orders for fries and Diet Pepsis. Wendy took his stuff to the table. He was so proud of his new-found expertise that he left his drink. I attempted to carry the cheesesteak, fries, and two drinks myself. Unfortunately, my sandwich tipped, creating a waterfall of greasy juice to cascade down my brand-new shirt and shorts.

But as Michael, the custodian at the Cathedral of Saints Peter and Paul, said, “You can’t really enjoy a Philly cheesesteak without getting some of it on your shirt.”

Hence, total success.

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Jim Thorpe's Infamous Dumb Crook

At the Old Jail in Jim Thorpe, PA, the story goes that one prisoner was convicted of a relatively minor offense and sent to jail for 120 days. After a time, he decided he could not stay. He wanted out and made plans to escape.

The most daunting problem, however, was that the windows were long—about thirty-six inches—but very narrow. Maybe eight inches. The tour guide showed us a window and it looked like a wide yardstick. So our genius determined that he needed to lose weight and stopped eating his meals. This was probably not much of a sacrifice. However, Albert Einstein did save the butter off all his trays and stash them for the big move.

Finally, the day came. He believed himself thin enough and greased his body with the stashed butter. Two buddies helped him wriggle through the narrow window, feet first. A lady was sitting on her porch enjoying her lunch when she caught sight of the naked fellow writhing his way out of jail. She quickly called the warden to inform him of the attempt.

Apparently, the warden merely gave the woman a verbal pat on the hand since her story was too far-fetched to be considered. And besides, he was on his own lunch break. But even in those days, he knew enough to cover his ass, because he called for a head count after the meal.

Lo and behold, one guy was missing. A manhunt was called, but it did not last long. They quickly found the greasy escapee in his own home, hiding under his bed. (“They’ll never find me here!") After all the planning and starvation, this brainiac made his break in the brightness of the noonday sun.




Sunday, June 12, 2011

Our Magical History Tour

Downtown Jim Thorpe
On the first full day of our Magical History Tour, we traveled to the village of Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania. The small town along the Lehigh River was originally named Mauch Chunk, but in 1954, the townspeople decided to rename the community after the 1912 Olympic hero. Ironically, the person Jim Thorpe had no connections with the town in life, but his wife liked the community and collaborated with them to commemorate her husband there. Born in Oklahoma, Jim Thorpe is now buried in Jim Thorpe, Pennsylvania.

The Old Jail
The town’s other claim to fame is the 1877 trial and execution of seven Molly Maguires, a group suspected of stirring the emotions of miners in their struggle for a decent wage.


The gallows

We visited The Old Jail, the location of the simultaneous hanging of four of the convicted men. A replica of the gallows was the focal point of the main cell block. Opened in 1871, the jail is now very decrepit. Mom found it so creepy as to be unnerving. The cells are fairly small, yet they housed up to four inmates each. A foul toilet and cot made up the contents of each cell.  

The basement of the jail held the dungeon, which consisted of sixteen cells used for solitary confinement. There was not even a vile toilet in these cells; prisoners were forced to use a bucket. Light was blocked resulting in total darkness for those unfortunates sent there. Shackles are attached to each wall to remind us what rambunctious prisoners faced.

How far she has fallen!
It was a little hokey, however, that they put fake webs and spiders along the walls. Where were the squeaking rats that surely must have inhabited these quarters? Manikins that had been fashion plates in a former life were placed in two of the cells. Their goal was to show us what a woman prisoner might look like with her hand on her hips in the corner of a cell. Weird.

It was a very interesting experience that I found quite thought-provoking. More on this later.